Masky x M!Reader x Jeff Chapter 10

"Osama?" BEN asked.

"Yup it's like truth or dare but we use sticks! One stick has a red mark and that's the king stick. Everyone else gets a random numbered stick and then we play! Get some people and I'll show you!"

BEN shrugged and walked off to find people while I got some Popsicle sticks out; numbering them but only putting a red mark on one. It's been almost a month since I started living at the creepypasta mansion and somehow I've been able to keep my mom's death a secret from my dad.

Ten minutes passed and BEN returned with Jeff, Masky, Hoodie, Toby, E.J., L.J., Lost Silver, and to my surprise Jane. Perfect. I smirked and had everyone pick a random Popsicle stick while I kept the red marked one for me. "To begin I will be 'king' so you can see how the game is played," I said happily.

"Alright we have nine soooooo Hm....... Numbers 2 and 7 switch underwear." I watched relief pass over some of their faces but Jeff and Jane however...... I started cracking up once they realized I said their numbers and soon they were glaring at each other. "NO WAY!" Jane yelled while Jeff scowled. "Rules are rules," I told them happily while everyone barely held in their laughter. Except for Laughing Jack: he was practically dying.

After Jane and Jeff left to switch underwear, Jeff looked a but awkward while walking. "Problems?" BEN teased him, earning a hard punch to his shoulder. As everyone randomly drew the random sticks, the expressions on my victims showed I will regret this.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

An hour into the game, all hell was breaking loose. BEN and Jane had swapped clothes (I took pictures for BEN blackmail), Lost Silver and Toby had to let Sally give them a makeover (again I took pictures), L.J. was wearing a tutu after Hoodie was forced to put one on him,and Jeff had to have a make-out session with E.J. So far Masky and I had managed to escape the king's grasp so we were pretty happy.

I spoke too soon.

"Numbers 1 and 2 need to go see Slenderman and ask him for condoms," a bitter BEN growled. "Um I'm number 2," Masky said. I looked at him with wide eyes before smirking. "Well lets go get condoms!" The others were laughing as Masky and I headed off to Slendy's office though I didn't care. This was an easy one.

"Hey Slendy we need a-"

"(y/n)!"

My eyes widened when my dad pulled me into a hug. Fuck this just got harder. While my dad hugged me and started to ask me questions i motioned for Masky to continue. Hell no I'm not asking now. He sighed and braced himself.

"Slenderman (y/n) and I need condoms. Do you have any? We need them now."

The silence that followed was horrible. I shot a look at my dad and saw his face darken while Slenderman's tentacles made themselves known. "What... We're you planning on doing with my precious baby boy, Masky?" My dad asked coldly. Both of us ran out of the office like the devil himself was chasing after us.

After that my luck went down the gutter. I ended up having to French kiss BEN (much to the amusement of Jane though Jeff and Masky seemed pretty pissed), tell Toby my darkest secret (it was so bad he stopped twitching after hearing it), talk dirty to L.J., and ugh..... grab Jane's ass. Neither of us enjoyed it. Though L.J. was in tears when I talked dirty to him and blushing badly. Well I'm glad someone appreciates my dirty talk!

"Alright well this is the last round cause I can't take much more!" I exclaimed picking a Popsicle stick. Everyone else picked one. "Um I'm the king...," Lost Silver's gentle voice informed us. "Um.... Number 9 have a heated make-out session with number 5 for five minutes." Woah did not think he had it in him! "Well I'm number 9," I said while looking around for number 5. The horrified expression on Jeff's face was enough of an indicator.

Grinning I straddled his lap and pulled him into a kiss before he could try running away. After a few seconds he gave in and started kissing back. It didn't take long for the kiss to turn into a hot make-out session and holy shit he's a good kisser! I felt him force his tongue into my mouth while his hands moved to my ass. Normally I'd pull away but instead I started to moan into the kiss which just made our kiss more desperate on his end.

Someone cleared their throat loudly and immediately we broke the kiss to see several embarrassed people, a laughing L.J., a smirking BEN and Jame, and a pissed off Masky. I was about to make a joke to cut the tension but then I felt something poking me. Of course I looked down out of curiosity and my eyes grew wide then I shot a smirk at Jeff. "The kiss feel good Jeff?" I teased then noticed his hands were still on my ass.

He noticed as well and quickly shoved my off his lap and crossed his legs. I glared at him while Masky gently pulled me to my feet. "Thank you Masky," I said happily before smirking at BEN. "Get any good pictures, princess?" He growled at me, making me laugh when I noticed Masky and Jeff glaring at each other. The fuck is wrong with those two?

With a shrug I threw the sticks away while everyone started to take off new clothes or trade back clothes. Next time I think we should play 7 minutes in heaven or spin the bottle.